An Argument for Open Source Intelligence Secrecy


“There is altogether too much discussion about the deliverables that OSINT [open source intelligence] can produce,” said Jennifer Sims, a former State Department intelligence official, at a DNI conference on open source intelligence last week.

Open source intelligence refers to intelligence that is derived from unclassified, legally accessible information sources.

But the fact that the underlying sources of OSINT are unclassified doesn’t mean the resulting intelligence can be disclosed, said Dr. Sims, who is now director of intelligence studies at Georgetown University.

“If it is providing decision advantage [to policymakers], then it is sensitive” and it should be withheld from disclosure, she said. “And decision advantage has nothing to do with the classification of the sources and methods. It has to do with the insights that the intelligence can deliver.”

Consequently, “OSINT needs to become a bit more closed-mouth about its deliverables,” she said.

By the same token, said Dr. Sims, if it’s not classified, then intelligence agencies should not be doing it.

“Democracies should sharply curtail classified intelligence organizations to the business that absolutely must be kept secret: gaining and keeping decision advantages in national security policy-making. Everything else should be unclassified and funded outside the intelligence establishment,” she wrote in an email message.

“Of course, if the processing of open sources gains you those insights, then ‘OSINT’ must be one of the jobs that intelligence institutions perform. But the measure of its success will always be the competitive edge it provides; and edges disappear if you give them away.”

The argument for greater open source intelligence secrecy suggests that U.S. intelligence agencies have been recklessly broadcasting OSINT products and thereby compromising the unique advantages that they provide. But most OSINT products are withheld from the public anyway.

And although some OSINT products have reportedly been included in the President’s Daily Brief, few of them seem to offer operationally significant insights that could be compromised by disclosure.

“Copyright, not classification, is the main barrier to disclosure of OSINT products,” said Kim A. Robson, deputy director of the DNI Open Source Center. But she added that “The better we get at OSINT, the more the need to classify it.”

Dr. Sims’ views were reported in “Analysis: Classifying open source intel?” by Shaun Waterman, United Press International, September 16.

A new recruitment video for the DNI Open Source Center presents the Center as it sees itself and would wish to be seen by potential recruits. A copy of the seven-minute video is posted here.

See also Open Source Intel Rocks — Sorry, It’s Classified by Noah Shachtman, WIRED Danger Room, September 17.

Source: FAS – Secrecy News


One response

  1. Huge number of e-tailers all over the planet at the present time encounter the problem of migrating their online retailers from the existing shopping cart to a top one. This manage is reasonably hard, specially for power traders, who is the owner of quite a few stockrooms and for the owners of heavy online supplies. Transferring all store’s content manually possibly will take you a long time and there’s no assurance you will do all perfectly.
    All you have to do is register on the website and choose the type of migration: your current shopping cart and target one. Then you should do – decide on what exactly you would like to migrate: requests, shoppers products or, maybe, all content of the store. To view how the migration will be accomplished you can preview Demo migration: choose 10 products, sale, purchasers etc and see how Cart2Cart moves selected entries into other shopping cart.
    Your current platform seems not to meet with the needs of your store any longer or you just want to switch to the one of the most popular commercialplatform on the web. It’s a smart decision as your business should be always developing to meet the increasing requirements of customers. You have been dwelling on moving to other platform long ago but haven’t done this yet? What is the reason? Most likely the fact that worries you is that transition process most likely will be rather challenging and will take a lot of time. You don’t have to bother about it any longer. There’s magnificent online shopping cart migration service that will assist you to resolve this obstacle.
    Perhaps till now everybody already understands what is e-commerce and what can it do. This fresh tendency in the planet of ecommerce is due to the existence of Shopping Carts or E-Commerce Platforms.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: